Undercrank Productions, the independent DVD/Blu-ray label founded by silent film accompanist/historian Ben Model, has announced that the fourth volume of Accidentally Preserved, a DVD series featuring rare silent comedy shorts rescued from obscurity by dedicated film collectors, will be coming to an Amazon Create-a-Space near you this fall. In addition to the usual line-up of mirthmakers (this time featuring Lige Conley, Glenn Tryon, and Bobby Ray, among many others), Accidentally Preserved 4 will spotlight a couple of real (reel) rarities: a one-reel edition of an early Colleen Moore feature, The Ninety and Nine (1922), and the two-reel version of a Mae Marsh Vitagraph feature, The Tides of Passion (1925—this is all that remains of the film).
in June of 2013, and Accidentally Preserved 2 got the ClassicFlix treatment a year later. So I guess this means that Volume 3 is back in Thrilling Days of Yesteryear’s court, and I apologize for taking so long with this—I received my copy nearly a year ago in August, and just now got around to freeing the DVD from its shrink-wrap prison. (I owe Ben reviews of the Marcel Perez and Musty Suffer releases, too—which I will pursue on future Thursdays.) This time around, Ben pressed upon some of his fellow collectors to contribute some of their treasures for the newest AP project (Facebook amigos like Rob Farr and Ralph Celentano), and the result was yet another eclectic compilation sure to win the hearts of silent cinema fans—an excellent example of that song lyric from A Funny Thing Happened On the Way to the Forum: “Something for everyone—a comedy tonight!”
“The first two volumes did really well, and when I ran out of films from my own collection, collectors I knew kept offering me titles from their own archives for the series,” Ben said in a press release for AP3 from September of 1915. “Collectors liked the idea of the DVDs, and felt as I did that these obscure gems deserve to be seen in a quality physical package. While hundreds of shorts were released in the 1920s, a huge amount are missing today. What's encouraging is that more of them turn up every year. In fact, one of the films on this DVD was won on eBay last year by a silent film collector here in NYC who's in the 7th grade.”
It was interesting to see Billy in something other than the Mickey McGuire comedies (where he played Mickey’s Kid Brudder), but the Half a Hero excerpt is a fairly lackluster affair, and seems to have been filmed as a silent before dialogue and sound effects were added in post-production (the dialogue is mostly out of sync with the actor’s mouths). I did enjoy the one-reel Whose Baby? (1929) a bit more; Arthur Lake—The Man Who Would Be Dagwood in movies and on radio and TV—is the star (a Horace in Hollywood comedy from Universal) of an amusing short in which his plans to make time with a pretty girl (Gertrude Messenger, on whom I have a bit of a classic film crush) are scotched when he suddenly acquires an infant; foisted upon him by a mother doing some shopping. I was aware that Lake did a number of comedy shorts for Universal in the 1930s (I don’t think many of them survived, sadly) but had not been briefed on his career in silents (he began making movies in 1924).
The 1921 Bobby Ray comedy Service a lá Bunk is a sprightly romp, with some inventive gags (Bobby gets to work via a little pedal car; he’s employed as a restaurant cook and he parks the vehicle in one of his ovens, taking special care to hang a “Garage” sign as he shuts the door) and Ray himself reminds me a little of Stan Laurel (it could be his derby) …which is interesting since Ray and Oliver Hardy were teamed in a few shorts produced by Billy West for Cumberland Productions in the mid-20s. My favorite comedy on AP3 is No Vacancies (1923), which stars Jay Belasco and Charlotte Merriam as a pair of newlyweds stymied by the housing shortage. They hatch a scheme where once they accept positions as janitor and maid for the ritzy Gibralter [sic] Apartments (“you need blasting powder to get in”), they’ll force some of the tenants to move so that they can rent the vacated apartment.
Opening up an envelope that the agent gave him, Belasco pulls out a note that reads: “Put up a tent.” Blanche Payson, the formidable actress who made such a memorable impression in the Our Gang two-reeler Dogs is Dogs (1931) and Laurel & Hardy’s classic Helpmates (1932), appears in this one, as does one of my favorite character actors from the world of silents, “foxy grandpa” Jack Duffy (thanks, Steve Massa, for the description). Duffy is also in Love’s Young Scream (1928), an amusing Paramount release produced by Al Christie—whose efforts often are ignored when the discussion focuses solely on the Sennett and Hal Roach studios as the premier laugh factories of their day.
(For the uninformed, croton oil was a powerful laxative sold in the 1910s/1920s.) This one puzzled the 120 experts at the “Mostly Lost” get-together held at the Library of Congress in 2014. (The author of Citrate is credited as Lucy Bowels, which will give you an idea of the Rabelaisian humor in this one.)
AP3’s remaining comedy is The Whirlwind (1922), starring Joe Rock. Rock was one-half of a successful duo (with Earl Montgomery) before becoming a producer and overseeing comedies with Stan Laurel, Jimmy Aubrey, and A Ton of Fun.
(I’m sure I’ve mentioned this before, but my friend Cliff of In the Balcony fame once told me of a revealing convo he had with a representative from one of the big companies: “People won’t buy black-and-white movies unless John Wayne is in them.”) I’ll have money in hand when Accidentally Preserved 4 is released, and I’ll do my best to let you know when that disc hits the mean streets of Create-a-Space.